Current Cover (3068 bytes)
Current Cover
Recent issues

2005 EDITOR's CHOICES --> | Industrial handhelds | Tablet PCs | Rugged notebooks | Handhelds and PDAs | MAIN

Pen Computing Magazine 2005 Editor's Choice Awards: 

Durable and Rugged Notebooks

The Pen Computing Magazine Editor's Choice Award is presented to products that score highest in a number of criteria. Among those criteria are overall concept and design, innovation, appropriate application of standard and advanced technology, usability, adherence to industry standards, price/performance, reliability, quality, features and competitive advantage. Each chosen product is, in Pen Computing Magazine's opinion, the best, or among the best, for its intended purpose in the class the award is given.

Itronix GoBook III
   


List price: from US$4,495
www.itronix.com
BEST HIGH PERFORMANCE RUGGED NOTEBOOK - The GoBook III is a technologically updated version of the GoBook II, which was a technologically updated version of the original GoBook. Itronix deliberately did not change the looks of the product nor did the company tamper with the overall design of this no-nonsense rugged notebook made almost entirely of magnesium alloy. The Go-Book III uses Intel’s 1.8GHz M745 processor which is significantly faster than the GoBook II’s 1.7 GHz Pentium 4. It also makes the GoBook run cooler and gives it noticeably better battery life (over five hours). Memory, disk, graphics and wireless options have all been modernized as well, resulting in a tried-and-true design that also represents the current technological state-of-the-art. Magnesium alloy construction and extensive shock absorption and sealing provide excellent environmental protection. Processor
CPU Speed
Standard/Max RAM
Disk/drive
Card slots
Display type
Display size/res
Color depth
Digitizer/pens
Keyboard/scale
Housing
Operating temp.
Sealing
Shock
Dimensions
Weight
Power
Interface
Interface
Options
Options
Pentium M Processor 745
1.8 GHz
256MB/2048MB
40 or 80 GB
2 PC Card Type II
Transmissive “ColorVue” TFT
12.1-inch/1024x768
16.7 million
Touchscreen   
Integrated 87 keys, 100%
Magnesium alloy
-10 to 140F (w/ HDD heater)
IP54
NA
12.0 x 9.8 x 2.36
8.2 lbs.
6,600 mAH Li-Ion (“5.25 hrs.”)
USB 2.0, VGA, RJ11, RJ45   
PS/2, serial, 802.11b, audio, dock   
Docks, 2nd battery, cases
Various wireless, Bluetooth, GPS
Panasonic Toughbook W2
   

 List price: from US$2,284
www.panasonic.com/toughbook
BEST SEMI-RUGGED ULTRA-PORTABLE - Panasonic designed the Toughbook W2 for those who like the T2’s size and weight, but also want an optical drive and even longer battery life. Normally, you’d expect the resulting machine to be larger and heavier. Amazingly, the W2 has a footprint identical to that of the T1, and despite the built-in DVD-CDRW drive it’s barely thicker and weighs about the same. That’s even more amazing considering the W2’s significantly larger battery (49 versus 33 Watt-Hours) that allow battery life in the six hour range. The W2 is part of Panasonic’s “semi-rugged” lineup; what this really means is that it’s largely made of magnesium and benefits from the company’s expertise in building longer-lasting computers that can take more abuse. However, don’t drop it off a cliff or leave it in the rain. The W2 ranks as one of the very best compact notebook solutions anywhere. Processor
CPU Speed
Standard/Max RAM
Disk/drive
Card slots
Display type
Display size/res
Color depth
Digitizer/pens
Keyboard/scale
Housing
Operating temp.
Sealing
Shock
Dimensions
Weight
Power
Interface
Interface
Options
Options
Intel Pentium M ULV 713
1.1 GHz
256MB/768MB
40GB HD + DVD-CDRW
1 PC Card Type II + 1 SD
Transmissive anti-glare TFT
12.1" XGA
16.7 million
none
integrated 85-key, 100%-scale
magnesium
semi-rugged
semi-rugged
semi-rugged
10.6 x 8.3 x 1.2-1.6
2.8 lbs.
49 Watt-Hour Li-Ion (“6 hrs.”)
2 USB 2.0, RJ11, RJ45   
Audio, VGA, 802/11b/g   
USB floppy, portfolio case
Chargers, battery pack
Panasonic Toughbook 29
 

  
 List price: from US$3,750
www.panasonic.com/toughbook
BEST RUGGED NOTEBOOK - The almost legendary Toughbook 29 is Panasonic’s most popular machine for field computing in harsh environments. With an all-magnesium housing, the rugged 29 sports excellent industrial design and—after the latest electronics update—most of the computing power of a state-of-the-art consumer notebook without the durability headaches that come with standard consumer products. The 29 is a very capable and flexible performer with a range of expansion options to suit any need. 802.11a/b/g WiFi is already built-in, and a larger power pack provides excellent battery life. It can be ordered pre-configured for several wireless data networks including the CDPD, GSM, GPRS and WiFi standards. The multi-purpose media bay, port panel, and PC Card bay are all protected under sealed doors; this notebook does not need a case, it is one. Processor
CPU Speed
Standard/Max RAM
Disk/drive
Card slots
Display type
Display size/res
Color depth
Digitizer/pens
Keyboard/scale
Housing
Operating temp.
Sealing
Shock
Dimensions
Weight
Power
Interface
Interface
Options
Options
Intel Pentium M LV 738
1.4 GHz
256-1536MB
60 or 80GB HD + FD/optical      
2 Type II PC Card
Transmissive anti-glare TFT
13.3"/1024 x 768 XGA
16.7 million
touchscreen optional
integrated 87-key, 100%-scale
Magnesium alloy
-20 to 140 degree F
IP54
26 x 3 feet drop to concrete
11.9 x 10.8 x 2.3
9.3 pounds (incl. battery + handle)
72 Watt-Hour Li-Ion (“7 hours”)
S/P, USB, RJ11, RJ45   
802.11a/b/g, audio, replicator
Wireless, Bluetooth, GPS, SmartCard
Dock, replicator, 2nd battery, drives
Twinhead Durabook N15 Series
   


List price: US$1,500 to 1,700
www.twinhead.com
BEST ECONOMY-PRICED SEMI-RUGGED NOTEBOOK - The Durabook N15 Series is aimed at those who want an economically priced semi-rugged notebook without giving up the vast screen real estate of a standard commercial notebook. All N15 Series models come with a 15.1-inch display. The top-of-the-line N15RB model has a 1400x1050 pixel LCD whereas the lesser N15RI and N15RN models have standard XGA (1024x768) resolution. The different models also come with a variety of processors, optical disk drives, and memory configurations. All share a magnesium case and excellent onboard connectivity. Despite their large display and considerable power, the N15s weigh less than seven pounds. And while they are not fully rugged, they pass limited drop, vibration, and sealing tests. The bottomline is a line of very durable, very well equipped notebooks that cost significantly less Processor
CPU Speed
Standard/Max RAM
Disk/drive
Card slots
Display type
Display size/res
Color depth
Digitizer/pens
Keyboard/scale
Housing
Operating temp.
Sealing
Shock
Dimensions
Weight
Power
Interface
Interface
Options
Options
Intel Centrino/Dothan/Pentium M
various
128-2048MB
20 to 80 HD + optical drive       
1 PC Card Type II
Transmissive TFT
15.1"/1400 x 1050 SXGA+
16.7 million
none
spill-proof 85 key, full-scale
Magnesium alloy
41 to 95 degree F
“spill-proof” (IP31)
2.5 foot drop
13.1 x 10.8 x 1.4
6.8 pounds
71 WHr Li-Ion (“3.5 hrs.”)
IrDA, 802.11b/g, 3 USB 2.0, S-Video   
Audio, RJ11, RJ45, VGA, IEEE1394
CPUs, optical drives, battery
Various RF